November 16, 2018, 10:55 am

Selling the Value of Reliability Improvement to Senior Management

Making your Proposition Resonate Emotionally

Providing the economic rationale for our proposal is necessary, but not sufficient.  As human beings, our emotions affect every decision that we make – in many cases in ways that we are not even aware of.  The evidence is that we tend to make initial decisions guided by our emotions, and then subsequently evaluate that decision using rational decision making criteria.  If you haven’t yet read Daniel Kahneman’s excellent book “Thinking, Fast and Slow”, then I strongly recommend that you do so, as this provides much more detailed discussion of these, and other related, concepts and the science behind them.

One of the pitfalls of our emotional brain is that it requires pretty powerful rational proof to overcome the initial, emotional decision that we made.  For this reason, it is important that we generate the right initial emotional response to our proposal. So how can we effectively swing the balance of emotions in our favour?  What are some of the keys to successfully tapping into the emotional side of decision makers?  Based on the excellent animation, which is, in turn based on a TED talk “The Science of Persuasion”, some of the key factors that influence others’ emotional responses to us are:

  • Empathy - Put simply, empathy is the ability to identify and understand another person’s feelings, ideas and situation. Research suggests that people are more likely to be persuaded by people that they like, and having empathy and a genuine interest in others is a key part of being liked.
  • Sincerity - When combined with empathy, sincerity leads to trust.  You need to be able to demonstrate through your behaviours and actions that you are sincere, and therefore worthy of trust – that you genuinely have the other parties best interests at heart.
  • Reciprocity - Reciprocity in social psychology refers to responding to a positive action with another positive action.  In more general terms, it means that if someone does you a favour, then you are more likely to feel obligated to do them a favour in return. In practice, what this means is that if you wish to have someone look favourably at your proposal, then you should do something good for them before you ask.  However, the good deed must be sincerely felt.  Research also suggests that the good deed will have more impact if it is personalised and unexpected.
  • Authority - In the context of effective persuasion, people tend to be persuaded more if the suggestion or recommendation comes from someone who is seen as both credible and authoritative in the subject.  So the key to success here is to either ensure that you are seen as credible and authoritative by the key decision makers, or enlist the support of someone else who is.  This person could be either internal or external to your organisation.
  • Consistency - People like to make decisions that are consistent with their previous statements and behaviours.  They are more likely, therefore, to support proposals that are consistent with the overall strategic direction of the organisation, the culture that exists within the organisation and any public pronouncements that they have made.  One key way of making use of this tendency is by gaining agreement from senior management to a smaller, less risky project first.  A pilot project, study or trial is more likely to be favourably viewed, and, if successful, it will be easier to gain commitment to a larger scale project.

One of the biggest emotional hurdles to be overcome is our emotional attitude to risk.  While we tend to believe that we can assess and manage risk in a rational manner (through risk matrices, formal risk management protocols etc), in practice, the data that we use to assess risk is imperfect, and as a result, our assessment of risk tends to be heavily influenced by our emotional attitude to risk.  It is almost universally true that our fear of loss tends to outweigh our desire for gain, and so one of the key activities that you will need to perform if you are to have your proposal accepted, is to identify the key risks that are associated with your proposal, and make sure that you have successfully addressed both the rational and emotional aspects of senior management’s likely responses to those risks, and can give management a sense of comfort that the level of risk is tolerable.  One possible approach that may enhance your chances of success is by taking advantage of management’s fear of loss by pointing out what they may miss out on if they don’t accept your proposal (rather than just focusing on what they may gain).  This may also assist in generating a sense of urgency around completing your project.

Conclusion

So there you have it – if you want to sell the value of Reliability Improvement to Senior Managers, you need to appeal to both their hearts AND their heads.

Sandy Dunn

Director - Assetivity

For future useful articles signup to our mailing list now.

Related Articles

Two reasons why team-based approaches to Root Cause Analysis (RCA) are more effective
 This is the second article in a series of four where we will examine the following topics:  Why Root Cause Analysis (RCA) is not just '...
Putting a value on maintenance and reliability improvement
Given that Assetivity’s business model is all about delivering value to our clients through improvements in asset management, maintenance management...
Reliability in Maintenance
In this article, we will explore four key ways in which Maintainers and Maintenance Management can impact on equipment reliability, and offer some...
5 Tips for a Better Asset Register
An organisation’s asset register is the foundation on which its Asset Information systems are built.  Dodgy foundations mean a rickety...
Reliability is Everybody’s Responsibility
As pilot-in-command, James finished his routine scan of his instruments and then sat back.  It was a beautiful day for flying; clear, cloudless...
Sign up to our Mailing List

Receive useful Maintenance & Asset Management articles, tools and news

assetivity logo